title banner
Essays by Juliet Waldron
 · Home · Juliet · Books · Essays · Blog · Facebook · Contact

How I met the Doctor

I was living in England with my mother, going to The School of St. Claire in Penzance as a day student. We lived in the end unit of a row house—stone houses, streets, little gardens—just as you might imagine a British working class neighborhood. We had just moved out of an artsy Mousehole hotel to less expensive Newlyn, to the last building on the top of the hill above the harbor. Behind us was a field with dairy cows and a stubby, well-worn stone circle, through which I walked every morning, taking the back way over the headland into PZ.

We rented our telly and paid license fees, like everyone else on the street, and I began watching my first regular doses of English entertainment. It was black and white in those days, fascinatingly different from what I’d been used to in the States.

I only saw two shows containing the original Doctor, and I’d stumbled into the middle of the first. Although I remember keenly enjoying the story, it was never completely clear to me what the heck was going on. I remember being thrilled to realize that this show was not only about history—and with costumes which were actually period correct (astonishing in and of itself  as this was the early sixties)—but also about the science fiction notion of time travel. The Doctor and his two companions eventually escaped from trouble inside a little blue box, the kind I’d seen standing, dusty and unused, on street corners here and there throughout British cities.

first doctor

William Hartnell

Well, wow! Stories about history and time travel all in one show!  The main character was not only mysterious, aged and professorial, but a little sinister, too, as if he was not entirely to be trusted. As someone who liked fantasy and science fiction but who had always been fascinated by reading about famous characters in history, I couldn’t help but be intrigued by what I was viewing. Unfortunately, no matter how much I waited for it, I never saw any more than those two shows. Soon Mom and I pulled up stakes again and headed for Barbados. In those days, the British West Indies had no TVs.

It was years later that the Doctor and I reconnected. My kids and I were sitting on the floor together watching public television on our Zenith, also parked on the floor. (In those days furniture was something of a luxury.)  A rather odd British import began. Lo and behold--there was my time traveler and his blue box—again! Of course, the original doctor had gone. The new one was still domineering and mysterious, but far less of a stuffy old professor. Instead he now appeared to be in his forties, with an extremely mod head of hair and late Victorian get-ups by way of Carnaby Street. He might have just stepped out of the Yellow Submarine.

Jon Pertwee as the doc

Jon Pertwee

Okay, I thought, I’ll go with the flow. My brief, earlier acquaintance with that absent minded elderly Doctor was a kind of pleasant itch, still lingering in my cranial filing cabinet. This, I realized, would be a great show for the kids to watch while I made dinner. (In those days 30 Minute Meals was not a marketable idea, just the way everybody cooked, especially if Mom worked the day shift.)

Doctor Who has always had rather tacky visuals. I was told by someone long ago that the Doctor’s eternal enemy, the Daleks, were actually tarted up shop vacs, hence their distinctive sloping can shape. (However, do remember that Twilight Zones weren’t all that much better. And what ‘60’s Trekkie can forget the embarrassing Gorn?) As an childhood watcher of s/f on TV—Captain Video, anyone?—I knew my imagination would do most of the work. If the concept was interesting, my brain would take it from there, just as it did when I read. Good actors and an involving story could carry off almost anything, because, as Hamlet says “the play’s the thing.” British actors, trained for the job, are, at least, skilled craftsmen, and adept at making theatrical magic happen with even the most minimal sets and effects.

The theme song I heard was as I’d remembered, appropriately far out. I believe it was the first television theme ever played on an electronic instrument, initially, perhaps (I don’t know for sure) on the exotic Theremin and later on the then new Moog synthesizer.

After my boys became fans, almost immediately there came a change in Doctors, as reported to me by my oldest son. He was about equally disturbed and fascinated by the fact that the main character in a series he was following might abruptly become someone else, all while essentially playing (more or less) the same character. This new Doctor immediately caught my eye—perhaps because his clothes were no longer Victorian mod, but utterly Bohemian trippy.

Tom Baker doc

Tom Baker

The hat, the scarf, the manic manner, the comic timing, his diction, and his “funny walks”—Baker was like a speaking, Oxford-educated Harpo Marx. The kids, and their Mom too, adored Baker, and we watched the show faithfully during the years of his reign. My youngest son begged his aunt to knit him a floor-sweeping Whovian scarf for Christmas, and we hunted used clothing stores for a cool old hat to go with it.

Time passed for us, as it never quite does in the TARDIS. The kids got older and began to lose interest when the Doctor regenerated next. We never entirely warmed to the handsome, dapper Peter Davison with his question marks and 1890s university cricketer’s garb. We drifted away.

Years went by. The kids grew up and had kids of their own. I went gray. Our “news” channels became so incompetent and corporate run that I looked for something else to watch at 5 o’clock. We’d just realized our cable would give us BBC America, and so I dropped over there, just to see.

KA-ZAM! There he was, a brand new Doctor! This show clearly had a budget and enjoyed the benefit of the CG revolution. Somewhere in the hiatus, our hoary old Doctor had become a valuable BBC property.

Chris Eccleston as doc

Christopher Eccelston

This new Doctor was different in a lot of ways, at first shockingly so. For one thing, he was an imposing guy with a buzz cut dressed in black leather, like a biker. Yikes! He also had a strong Northern working class accent, far removed from the mad scientist elite of the past. Double Yikes!

Christopher Eccelston only gave the series 13 episodes, but I think he did amazing work. He was an excellent choice for the Doctor’s 21st Century revival, the ninth reincarnation of the mystery man. This was a visceral, dangerous Doctor—as well as being, as usual, unpredictable and wizard-wise.  The new scripting, too, was exciting, the best writing yet, while firmly grounded in the tradition of the series.

Romance for the Doctor and his companion was another innovation that was a GOOD THING, adding some spice to the character’s lonely Flying Dutchman persona. (The “Companions” have been shorted in this reminiscence, but they’ve always been an integral part of the Whovian equation.) Rose Tyler and The Doctor shared the series’ first kiss. It was an electric moment.

David Tennant as doc

David Tennant

Suddenly, however, here came a new Doctor—and, I confess, my favorite. Bring on Doctor #10, the wonderful RADA actor David Tennant, an admitted “fan-boy” from childhood. Here we had a hyper, bi-polar Doctor, a veritable road runner on speed, wearing a duster, a shiny suit, and Converse sneakers.  This Doctor exhibited a ferocious brand of fey, peppered throughout with world-weariness and pessimism, all of it wrapped up inside one skinny Time Lord. Gilbert & Sullivan couldn’t write any better patter than Russell Davies, and their Doctor—and the rest of the fine ensemble--delivered the goods.

Regeneration into #11, and new writers have sent the show on a Matrix-out-of-Stephen-King turn. I’m slow to warm to this new Doctor, Matt Smith. All I can say for now is that like Merlin, the character seems to be aging backwards. Matt Smith’s costume is a look back into the Doctor’s “academic” past.  

There’s a particular Englishness to Doctor Who. It’s quirky, by turns scary or silly, before turning darkly philosophic. It’s also shamelessly self-referential, and full of puns plus literary, scientific and topical allusions which I adore. From Pratchett to Monty Python to Professor Quatermass, from forms as low as Pantomime and high as Shakespeare, all that’s delightful—and insightful--in British entertainment is woven together in:

Doctor Who, Greatest Show in the Galaxy.

David Tennant as doc

Read Juliet's thoughts on

 · Good-bye, Schuyler

 · How I met the doctor

 · Kick your ass yoga

 · Why I write historicals

 · Tolkien at the movies

 · Frodo Downsized